Europe’s institutional investors across Europe are reviewing their bond portfolios as negative yields reduce income and impact on their ability to meet and hedge their liabilities, reports Mercer.
According to the consultancy group’s newly-published 2016 Asset Allocation Survey pension schemes are also seeking to manage volatility – especially in the more mature markets. Average equity allocations across the region have reduced over the past year with a corresponding increase in allocations to alternative assets.
The survey gathers investment information from nearly 1,100 institutional investors across 14 European countries, reflecting total assets of around €930bn. The report also highlights that institutional investors have generally retained allocations to emerging markets, despite a sustained period of disappointing performance since 2013.
“It is encouraging to see institutional investors taking a long-term view in relation to emerging markets, in marked contrast to the behaviour of retail investors since the taper tantrum in 2013,” said Phil Edwards, European director of strategic research in Mercer’s Investments business. “We continue to advocate exposure to emerging markets as part of a well-diversified growth portfolio,”
In the UK, an increasing number of plans are adopting or considering a cashflow-driven approach to their funding and investment strategy. This trend corresponds with a rise in the proportion of plans that are now cashflow-negative and increasingly focused on what their ‘end-game’ looks like. In addition the report notes that, on average, smaller UK pension plans are more exposed to any market volatility associated with the European Union (EU) referendum on June 23.
Nathan Baker, principal in Mercer’s Investments business, “Although it’s not possible to know now with any certainty how the referendum will impact portfolios, a typical small UK plan is more UK-centric, more exposed to movements in sterling versus other currencies, and is managed in a less dynamic fashion.
On balance, they would appear more exposed to any associated volatility, and less well positioned to take advantage of it.”
The report highlights four main trends, two of which are specific to the UK:
Negative bond yields:
Although bond allocations across Europe in aggregate remained broadly flat over the year, schemes in regions experiencing some of the lowest yields, such as Sweden and Germany, saw bond exposures fall.
In general, within bond portfolios there has been a shift away from low- or negative-yielding domestic government bonds towards higher-yielding non-domestic and/or corporate bonds. The varied responses of plans across Europe to the challenge of negative yields reflect the complex interplay of regulatory constraints, the availability of acceptable alternatives and investor risk tolerance.
Although retail investor flows into/out of emerging markets remain volatile, institutional allocations have, on the whole, held steady. Despite a disappointing performance over several years, emerging markets continued to account for around 6% of overall assets (unchanged from 2015) and both emerging market equity and debt remain common components of institutional portfolios across Europe.
The rise of cashflow-driven financing:
The proportion of plans that are now cash flow negative (that is, when monthly outgoings to meet pension payments are higher than monthly contributions into the plan, leading to a cash demand on the asset portfolio) has risen from 37% to 42% since the 2015 survey. This has fuelled interest in income-generative assets and cash-flow-driven financing strategies. Such approaches involve the asset portfolio being tailored to more closely meet the projected liability cash flows while ensuring funding-level stability.
UK plans and the EU referendum:
Specific to UK schemes, smaller pension plans tend to have a higher exposure to UK assets (domestic markets occupy 30% of smaller plan equity portfolios versus 16% for larger plans), lower levels of currency hedging (the average hedge ratio is 39% for smaller plans versus 45% for larger plans), and a less dynamic investment strategy (trigger-based hedging strategies are less commonly used).
Although the impact of the referendum on capital markets remains unclear, the combination of these factors suggests that the “average” smaller plan may be more exposed to volatility associated with the referendum.
“Many markets are suffering from reduced liquidity which creates volatility; investors should be alert to and set up to capitalise on opportunities that market volatility may create,” said Baker.
“It’s also worth noting that some of the most recent developments in credit markets – increased leverage, weaker credit standards and an increase in merger and acquisition [M&A] activity – broadly mirror those that tend to be seen in the later phase of the credit cycle.
“These conditions argue for robust risk management – including consideration of tail risk protection where appropriate – as well as being alive to the opportunities that may arise in distressed debt.”
The European Central Bank will extend its quantitative easing programme for nine months beyond next March, but scale back the level of bond buying from €80bn to €60bn a month.
The agreement, after three years of debate, raise questions on future investment demand, but Fitch Ratings doesnʼt anticipate major market disruption.
The European Commission fined Credit Agricole, HSBC and JPMorgan Chase a total of €485m for manipulating the price of the financial benchmark.
Issuers should seek more engagement with investors, explain better how they generate value, and work with investors on a Swiss code of accountable governance, suggests a white paper.